What Is the Great Commandment According to the Bible?

TL;DR: The Great Commandment is Jesus' declaration that loving God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength is the first and greatest commandment in the law. When a scribe asked Him which commandment ranked highest, Jesus answered without hesitation. He also added a second commandment — loving your neighbor as yourself — saying the entire law and prophets hang on these two. It's the foundation of Christian ethics in Protestant teaching. Matthew 22:38 Mark 12:30

"Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy strength: this is the first commandment." — Mark 12:30

When a scribe approached Jesus and asked which commandment stood above all others, Jesus gave a direct, unambiguous answer Mark 12:28. He didn't hesitate or qualify His response — He pointed to total, wholehearted devotion to God as the supreme obligation of every human being Mark 12:30.

Matthew's account frames the question slightly differently, with a Pharisee asking which is the "great commandment in the law" Matthew 22:36, and Jesus confirming: "This is the first and great commandment" Matthew 22:38. Both Gospel accounts converge on the same truth — love for God isn't merely one duty among many; it's the organizing principle of all moral and spiritual life.

Protestant · Christianity

Protestant View of the Great Commandment

"Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy strength: this is the first commandment." — Mark 12:30

Protestant theology has historically treated the Great Commandment as the hermeneutical key to all of Scripture's moral teaching. When the Pharisees tested Jesus by asking "Master, which is the great commandment in the law?" Matthew 22:36, His answer wasn't a clever dodge — it was a definitive theological statement that love for God is the root from which all other obedience grows.

Reformers like Calvin and Luther emphasized that this commandment exposes humanity's total inability to fulfill God's law in their own strength, since loving God with every faculty — heart, soul, mind, and strength — is an absolute standard Mark 12:30. It's not partial devotion but complete, undivided allegiance. Mark's Gospel records Jesus saying explicitly, "this is the first commandment" Mark 12:30, and Matthew confirms it as "the first and great commandment" Matthew 22:38.

Protestant preachers frequently pair the Great Commandment with the second — loving one's neighbor — noting that Jesus said all the law and prophets hang on both. The scribe who heard Jesus' answer in Mark 12 recognized its wisdom immediately Mark 12:28, and Protestants see this exchange as proof that the moral law isn't abolished but fulfilled in love. Genuine faith, they argue, always produces this double love: upward toward God and outward toward others.

Key takeaways

Jesus identified loving God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength as the first and greatest commandment in the entire law. Mark 12:30
Both Matthew and Mark record this declaration, with Matthew's account explicitly calling it 'the first and great commandment.' Matthew 22:38
The question was posed by a scribe in Mark and a Pharisee-lawyer in Matthew, showing the commandment's importance across different Jewish groups. Matthew 22:36 Mark 12:28
Protestant theology treats the Great Commandment as the moral foundation from which all other biblical ethics flow, demanding total and undivided devotion to God. Mark 12:30
Jesus' answer was immediate and unqualified — no commandment in the law ranks above wholehearted love for God. Matthew 22:38

FAQs

Who asked Jesus about the Great Commandment?

In Matthew's account, a Pharisee who was a lawyer posed the question Matthew 22:36. Mark's Gospel records it as a scribe who had been listening to Jesus debate others and was impressed by His answers Mark 12:28. Both accounts capture the same pivotal exchange about the supreme commandment in the law.

Where exactly does Jesus declare this the greatest commandment?

Jesus explicitly states "This is the first and great commandment" in Matthew 22:38 Matthew 22:38, and in Mark 12:30 He concludes His answer by saying "this is the first commandment" Mark 12:30. The question that prompted it is recorded in Matthew 22:36 Matthew 22:36, making the full exchange one of the most quoted dialogues in the Gospels.

What does it mean to love God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength?

Mark 12:30 lists four distinct faculties — heart, soul, mind, and strength — indicating that love for God must be total and not compartmentalized Mark 12:30. Protestant theologians interpret this as a call to orient every dimension of human existence toward God. It's not an emotion alone but a comprehensive, whole-person devotion that shapes thought, will, and action Matthew 22:38.

Is the Great Commandment the same as the first of the Ten Commandments?

They're related but distinct. The first of the Ten Commandments forbids other gods, while the Great Commandment as Jesus stated it is a positive command to love God wholeheartedly Mark 12:30. Jesus framed it as the "first commandment" when asked which ranked highest among all the law's commands Mark 12:28, elevating it as the positive foundation underlying all prohibitions.

0 Community answers

No community answers yet. Share what you've read or learned — with sources.

Your answer

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to share an interpretation, source, or counter-argument.